Category: Election 2018

McDonnell Throws Tantrum After Union Endorses Villanueva for Sheriff

Struggling Sheriff Jim McDonnell flashed the anger, contempt and casual relationship with the truth he is known for Wednesday in responding to LASD’s largest union endorsing his challenger, retired Lieutenant Alex Villanueva.

In a graceless statement posted to his Facebook page, McDonnell said:

I’m not surprised by the announcement made by the Board of Directors of ALADS today. By endorsing my opponent, ALADS has endorsed a candidate who has publicly opposed the reforms underway that have reduced jail violence and increased accountability. He would take the Department backwards to a time of chaos and corruption like it was under Baca and Tanaka.

I have come in and implemented accountability measures and the ALADS Board has taken issue with that, and I am not going to apologize for holding accountable those who tarnish the badge.

Thousands of individual deputies and civilian personnel have indeed worked hard to earn back the trust of the public after many years of crisis. I do not believe the ALADS Board of Directors speaks for the overwhelming number of Deputies who are active partners in moving the Department forward. Together, we have a responsibility to make Los Angeles County as safe as possible while continuing to earn the public’s trust every day.

What an astonishingly passive-aggressive, dishonest, bridge-burning, and childish bunch of nonsense. Had ALADS endorsed him, McDonnell would’ve instead been talking about how honored and humbled he was for their support and partnership.

In other words: you don’t think I’m doing awesome so you’re part of the problem.

This sort of denial and blame-shifting wouldn’t be tolerated of a deputy sheriff trainee in the academy; we absolutely shouldn’t tolerate it from the elected sheriff. He’s had four years to learn our standards. This is Phase 1 roll-up behavior.

Is it any wonder McDonnell’s community relations are so fraid? That he was absent from much of the community for the last four years until, surprised into a runoff, he’s running around hat-in-hand, begging for money from wealthy West Siders? That he views the Citizens Oversight commission as his liaison to the community rather than an actual oversight panel?

Can you imagine if this guy were your boss and you had to disagree with him? (Demoted Captain Chris Brackpool can.)

What is this, Russia?

Petulant as McDonnell’s statement is, it’s a window into how his Father Knows Best mindset reacts when a partner dares to challenge him. No wonder suck-ups and sycophants have done so well promoting under McDonnell, especially all the Tanaka-acolytes who so quickly changed their colors?

McDonnell’s statement is completely unhinged.

Here are the facts:

  • Jim McDonnell has accomplished very little in four years as sheriff. Crime is up, proactive police work is way down, morale is probably the lowest its ever been, chancing arbitrary and career-altering/ending discipline by ambitious middle-managers and self-styled “executives” is viewed as a risk of showing up for work, acting with integrity is viewed as an act of foolishness, while the executive ranks themselves are riddled with suck ups and people with extensive records of misconduct (some quite recent).
  • Alex Villanueva hasn’t opposed significant reforms because McDonnell has neither made significant reforms nor even suggested what they might be. All he talks about is implementing systems of processes of layers of paper-pushers (all wearing brass belt buckles and sewn-down epaulettes, of course; all telling him how great he is). And this is without even getting to the 300 admin staff he says he’d need to run a body cam program.
  • In fact, the only major McDonnell “reform” LASD.News can recall Villanueva opposing was releasing an informal list of deputies previously accused of having integrity issues to the District Attorney’s office (the so-called “Brady List”), including its apparently intentional and criminal leak to the media. And the reason Villanueva has given for disagreeing is not that he opposes the list in principle but because the list is not accurate–it includes people who don’t even know they’re on it or why they would be; it includes people who were bullied into accepting a punishment that without their knowledge landed them on the list rather than risk loss of pay while fighting an internal case; indeed the Los Angeles Times has itself reported that deputies have been removed from the list after someone realized they were there in error. That McDonnell is comfortable needlessly and perhaps falsely tarnishing peoples’ reputations to achieve the appearance of having achieved something says more about him than it does about anyone else.
  • Actually, Villanueva has campaigned extensively on the assertion that McDonnell’s reforms have been fake in effect, not that they’ve been wrong in intent.
  • Indeed, under McDonnell’s leadership numerous deputies have been arrested or convicted of crimes, firings have gone through the roof (as have reinstatements through the legal system and back-pay awards), including firings of “executives” McDonnell sought to defend one day and kicked out the window the next. As any deputy knows, firing is viewed internally now as a management stunt easily and often entered into to make the lawyers happy and “leaders” look good, with the understanding that the legal appellate process will do the actual managing.
  • By the way, anyone know what’s going on with Todd Rogers’ civil suit against McDonnell alleging he was retaliated against after the last election? Did the County settle that one yet?
  • And speaking of integrity issues, what does it take for McDonnell to end up on his own Brady List, with all his own false statements? Such as when he told the media last year that no uses of force had been recorded on deputies’ personally-owned body cams (which they have bought due to his refusal to distribute them)? Or his claiming above that an “overwhelming number of deputies” support him in “moving the Department forward” when, in fact, 97% of deputies voted their lack of confidence in McDonnell? Or his many false statements to reporter Annie Gilbertson in her REPEAT Podcast (especially episodes 5 and 6)? He must know what he is saying is false, but he’s saying it so his LA-establishment backers who don’t know how failed and unpopular he is, who will simply take his word for it.
  • While McDonnell claims to be a reformer, in fact he hasn’t gotten much done–other than gorging on the vain perks of his office: his $2 million luxury SUV and entourage, the hats and jackets and uniforms and brass buckles and the decals, LASD’s new theme song (which deputies can listen to when the countywide radio system crashes), the travel, and the use of county resources for campaign purposes, and the mountain retreats, to say nothing of his nearly half-million dollars in annual taxpayer-funded compensation.
  • McDonnell’s attitude–and that of his supporters–seems to be that if the unions disapprove of his performance, he must be doing something right. That’s cute, except LASD’s unions endorsed him four years ago and have complained constantly since then not about McDonnell’s policy positions but mostly about his lack of vision, understanding of the organization, and his leadership. They’ve complained about his not responding when a deputy was shot in the neck because it was late at night. They’ve complained about his ineffectiveness; about his inability to recruit, about the wave of deputies immediately lateraling to other agencies, about being $200 million over budget, about detectives being put into patrol cars to achieve minimum patrol levels. The unions are raising serious concerns about a sheriff which experience is showing is not up to the job. (See, also.) You can ignore the warning light if you like, but that doesn’t mean you aren’t going to crash into the mountain.

Maybe this frequent commenter on the LA Times article summed it up best:

“I think Jim is the biggest let-down of ANY elected official in the last 25 years,” she said. “Now even I refer to Jim as Sheriff McBuckles. Sad. So disappointing. Jim, I hate to say this b/c I was such a huge fangurl, you had your chance and choked. Time to step aside my friend.”

Indeed. And drop the patch.


ALADS Endorses Villanueva for Sheriff

The Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs (ALADS) dropped a bombshell Wednesday when it announced it had endorsed Alex Villanueva to be the next Los Angeles County Sheriff.

The endorsement mirrors a similar situation in Riverside County, where strong support from the deputies’ union allowed Lieutenant Chad Bianco to force unpopular Sheriff Stan Sniff into a fall runoff. Like the LASD, Riverside Sheriffs are also dealing with historically low morale, a sense the department is mismanaged at every level, a lack of progressive thinking, and an inability to recruit or retain deputies headed for early retirement or greener pastures at other agencies. They, too, are a mess. And their union has taken a similarly strong stand to bring about reform.

In an email to deputies, ALADS President Ron Hernandez explained, “Alex is one of us… He has been a tireless advocate for deputies, especially during moments in the department’s history when it was necessary to speak truth to those in power. Alex’s track record demonstrates an ability to initiate reform while staying acutely connected to our needs and experiences. His impressive primary election campaign has already shown how he can raise morale, inspire and represent us.”

The endorsement comes after 97% of deputy sheriffs voted no confidence in McDonnell in a survey earlier this year. Only 34 of the over 1,400 deputies responding to the survey felt confident in McDonnell’s leadership.

“The underlying sentiments which drove responses should certainly be of concern to Sheriff McDonnell,” ALADS said at the time. “In particular, the Sheriff should take note that this vote represents a loss of confidence in him by a significant number of his deputies.”

The endorsement also comes after a primary election in which McDonnell, who won 75% of the vote less than four years ago, couldn’t muster more than 48%, despite huge name recognition, rock-solid establishment support, conventional wisdom you cannot beat an incumbent, the endorsement of the Los Angeles Times, and a half-million dollars in fundraising (mostly from wealthy West LA/Beverly Hills types–the same trough he’s going back to now in the general election).

It also comes after Villanueva pulled in over 30% of the vote, despite little name recognition, virtually no budget or campaign machine like those fielded by challenger Bob Lindsey and incumbent McDonnell. Rather, what Villanueva offered was the assertion that McDonnell’s reform was fake and impermanent and the view that it was possible to chart a progressive vision for Southern California law enforcement in a way that also supports the men and women placing themselves in harm’s way.

The early and strong endorsement is especially noteworthy given ALADS’ declining to make an endorsement in the primary election (while the deputy sheriff contract was under negotiation) and given the significant resources that will now be made available to Villanueva.

While McDonnell’s support was strongest among wealthier, white, establishment types, Villanueva found strong support among African Americans, Hispanics, and those with whom LASD’s relationship is supposedly most strained. 


Now that ALADS has endorsed Villanueva, you can expect many other Southern California labor unions to follow suit, due to an unwritten rule that they tend to follow the lead of the largest union at each organization. The endorsement also signals that ALADS may use its significant political budget to advocate for Villanueva.

Here is ALADS’ statement in full:

Fellow Deputies,

Today we have announced our endorsement of Alex Villanueva in the November 2018 election for Los Angeles County Sheriff. He embodies the essential characteristics and values required to lead the department: integrity, honesty, tenacity, courage, and connectivity with his fellow deputies.

This decision comes after serious deliberation amongst our Board of Directors and numerous conversations with you – the members whom we represent and serve. It is our firm belief that the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department needs to be transformed and that Alex is best suited to lead that change given his background, skills, and character.

Alex is one of us. He has over three decades of experience as a deputy, has served in the United States Air Force and the California Army National Guard, and earned a Doctorate in Public Administration while studying the impact of diversity on law enforcement leadership. He has been a tireless advocate for deputies, especially during moments in the department’s history when it was necessary to speak truth to those in power.

Alex’s track record demonstrates an ability to initiate reform while staying acutely connected to our needs and experiences. His impressive primary election campaign has already shown how he can raise morale, inspire and represent us.

Please feel free to contact any of your board representatives if you have any questions or concerns.

Ron Hernandez

Sheriff’s Debate Tonight: Here Are The Details

The Professional Peace Officers Association (one of the three unions representing the LASD) is holding a debate tonight between the two remaining candidates to be your next Los Angeles County Sheriff: Alex Villanueva and Jim McDonnell.

The debate will run from 5-6:30 p.m. and be streamed on PPOA’s Facebook page.

While Villanueva and primary election challenger Bob Lindsey participated in several debates during the primary election cycle, McDonnell arrogantly blew off the debates. While he took 75% of the vote three years ago against a felon to win election, he will now have to run on his record against a long-time LASD member and reformer, a Hispanic, and someone who has found a deep well of support in the communities LASD’s relations are (the media says) most strained. Meanwhile, McDonnell’s support comes mainly from those served the least by the LASD (and the least familiar with it). A lot of wealthy white people living along the coast. Witness LA thinks it’ll be a real horse race.


Graphic Source: LA Times

As you may remember, 97% of nearly 2,000 deputies who participated in a recent poll by the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs (another LASD union) voted their lack of confidence in McDonnell. PPOA President Brian Moriguchi and other board members have also been increasingly critical of the department’s accelerating decay.

Tonight’s debate will be moderated by Adrienne Alpert from ABC 7, who has interviewed McDonnell several times before (such as here and here). Other panelists will include Moriguchi, Marcel Rodarte from the Contract Cities Association, and Marjorie Green from the League of Women Voters. It will be held at LAPD headquarters (aka McDonnell’s Mothership).

For more information about the debate, click here.

PPOA will be live-streaming the debate on its Facebook page.

LA Sheriff Candidate Alex Villanueva Could Unseat Struggling McDonnell. How Did It Happen?

It’s a consequence of today’s media echo-chamber that we mostly hear opinions we agree with and we have the freedom to mute those we don’t. And so it was after last month’s primary election that everybody had got it wrong.

Supporters of Jim McDonnell thought he’d coast to an easy re-election. In fact, McDonnell told as much to KFI host Tim Conway the day before the primary. Sure, his performance over the last three years has disappointed almost everyone, and sure most people at LASD despise him and he doesn’t have the credibility to lead a gaggle of ducks, and sure his claim to have abracadabra’d a “sea change” in LASD’s culture is nonsense belied by the facts, and sure crime has gone up and he hides stuff from the community, and sure he’s incredibly arrogant and spends lavishly on himself and vanity projects, and sure he’s blown the budget and a bunch of deputies and professional staff have gone to jail for sex crimes and serious felonies on his watch, and sure we’re hearing the OIG recently issued a report deeply critical of the lack of reform in LASD’s tailspinning Custody Division, and sure he’s been revoking CCWs from retirees injured on duty and destroyed the Reserve program, and sure he’s a conservative white guy in a time when progressive electorates are shying away from conservative white guys, and sure he took the public’s trust for granted and ran a half-assed campaign … BUT he had nearly $600K in donations from rich LA City establishment types in the bank, and a Boston accent after four decades in LA, and the media said incumbent sheriffs don’t lose, and it was a LOCK. And then McDonnell, who received 75% of the vote three years ago, and possibly the least explicable or enthusiastic LA Times endorsement in history, came in at 47%. Against two LASD veterans he was too arrogant to debate.

Bob Lindsey’s team also felt confident. Many say they don’t know a single person who voted for McDonnell. After six months of full-time campaigning and nearly $800,000 in donations, Lindsey stunned many with a significant though disappointing 18% of the vote.

And then there was the dark-horse: Alex Villanueva. With just $27,000 in donations and a minimal campaign, Villanueva walked away with 33% of the vote. Many experts close to the other campaigns assumed he’d get 3-6%; 12% tops.

What happened?

Celeste Fremon at Witness LA has the story

Times Says McDonnell Should Be Scared of Villanueva’s Strong Support

We hope everyone had a happy and safe 4th, especially everyone working the streets and cell blocks.

LASD.News was working a lot ourselves the past few days ourselves so apologizes for missing this one, but the LA Times had a long story a few days ago about Alex Villanueva’s surprisingly strong showing in the primary.

Click here to see the story.

“Had Jim McDonnell called me in February or so, I would have said, ‘What are you worried about? Look at who’s running against you. Relax,’” one political analyst told the Times. “I would have been completely wrong.”

The problem, of course, is that the analyst’s opinion would not have taken into account how much McDonnell is despised by the people who work for him, how disappointed Los Angeles County voters are by his performance, and how much they may be interested in voting for somebody younger, with fresher ideas…who isn’t another white politician.

“If I were part of the McDonnell campaign, it would certainly concern me,” another analyst told the Times. “Anytime you have spent multiples more [than an opponent] and then you end up in a runoff, it’s cause for pause and soul searching and concern.”

Except McDonnell doesn’t strike us as the soul searching kind of guy. Because he’s an aloof and arrogant kind of guy.

You can check out the story for yourself by clicking here.  But also check out this cool map the Times did of how the county voted in the primary.

While there’s a lot of McDonnell on that map (though most of it is bushes and dirt), just imagine how it might look if Lindsey backers threw their weight behind Villanueva and if Villanueva–who is a Democrat and, like Mayor Garcetti, speaks Spanish–had some money behind him.

(We think McDonnell was a Republican, is now an independent, and doesn’t habla.)

The LAPD decided 2018 wasn’t the year for a woman or a Hispanic police chief. But maybe it’s the county’s year for a Hispanic sheriff…?

Villanueva definitely seems to be the choice of the people LA’s liberals (and McDonnell himself) say LASD needs to builds better relations with.


Alex Villanueva Forces Weakened McDonnell Into November Runoff

A dark pall fell over the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department Tuesday night with the news that Bob Lindsey failed in his bid to become sheriff and that the department may be saddled with four more years of Jim McDonnell, who is viewed by many as destroying the department through his mismanagement.

That was definitely the mood on election night when LASD.News was working the field. Deputies were in a state of shock and despair, unable to comprehend the emerging vote count. Many confidently asserted the count must have been rigged. Many said they didn’t know a single McDonnell supporter. One said they know knew how Hillary voters must have felt. Another deputy likened the mood inside LASD to that of a prison camp. There was talk of an “exodus” from LASD to other agencies which are aggressively recruiting, though the likelihood of this may be limited by non-compatible retirement programs.

“The results may have been ‘a double surprise’ for McDonnell, who appeared to be confident and more focused on his daily responsibilities than on his re-election campaign,” Jorja Leap, a UCLA professor affiliated with McDonnell told the Long Beach Press Telegram.

The Press Telegram continued: “Not only will there be a runoff in November but Villanueva also received one third of the vote, which is significant, Leap said. And this happened, she said, despite McDonnell’s past performance of calming the turbulence created by the previous administration of then-Sheriff Lee Baca and Undersheriff Paul Tanaka, who were both sentenced in connection with a jail abuse and corruption scandal.”

LASD watchdog observed: “Now that the sheriff has a record he must defend until November, we are sure things are going to get bloody. Since Sheriff McDonnell can no longer hide from public debate as he has enjoyed to this point, we believe he will attempt to phony his way thru to November running on a record which has largely failed.  One only needs to read the flaccid LA Times endorsement that pointed out McDonnell’s many failures to know this sheriff is vulnerable to defeat. To Alex, nobody understands how you made second place among opponents who out spent you by a tremendous margin, but you are clearly the only choice for sheriff.  Don’t let us down.”

And indeed that seemed to be the direction of things Wednesday.

As the grieving process has moved forward, the focus has shifted to what next. What will Bob do? What will his large, enthusiastic team do? Was Villanueva’s surprise win a vindication of his campaign, or mainly his strong Democratic affiliation and non-Anglo Saxon last name? How will McDonnell respond to being in a runoff against someone six ranks his junior? How will Villanueva come off on that stage? 

Though there are few answers Wednesday night, some hints are emerging.

Professional Peace Officer Association President Brian Moriguchi posted a video Wednesday promising that PPOA would aggressively vet both candidates and throw its financial resources behind its preferred candidate.

Meanwhile, deputies brought to LASD.News’s attention a photo posted to McDonnell’s Facebook page of ALADS President Ron Hernandez from 2014. This, of course, is noteworthy given Hernandez’ refusal to take a position on the primary election, despite deputies by 97% voting no confidence in McDonnell. ALADS did not appear to have made any statement about their intentions by Wednesday night.


In his own statement Wednesday, Villanueva seemed emboldened and confident:

“Considering the fact that Villanueva was outspent 50 to 1 by both his opponents combined, a forced runoff was a stunning upset for the embattled incumbent… Our message of ‘Reform, Rebuild, Restore’ resonated with the people of Los Angeles County,” Villanueva said (see below).

Lindsey also released a statement (also below), thanking his supporters.

In his post, Villanueva then extended an olive branch: “We appreciate the spirited campaign by Mr. Lindsey and his supporters contributions toward forcing the runoff. We both agree the Department requires a change in leadership now, a consensus confirmed by the voters.”

He concluded: “Thank you to all those who placed their faith in us and voted. And we hope by November, to earn the votes of those who did not. Again, thank you.”

McDonnell, by contrast, still had no statement posted to his campaign Facebook page by Wednesday night. Because he’s such a great leader…

We didn’t vote for Mr. Villanueva. And we encouraged you, Dear Reader, to vote for Bob Lindsey. That was then, this is now. Will Alex rise to the occasion? This is a promising, though early, start.





Bob Lindsey on John and Ken

Bob Lindsey spoke on the John and Ken program for about a minute tonight. You can listen to it by clicking here and skipping to 99 minutes in.

Also today, Jim McDonnell recorded a video from what appears to be a park. Possibly an up-scale homeless encampment (one of the county’s thousands).

Then he went on Tim Conway Jr’s show (also on KFI), though this is less newsworthy than 60 seconds in John and Ken because Conway gives McDonnell a fawning reception virtually every month. You can hear the interview here.

Though Conway’s fans seemed none too pleased.


Meanwhile, Alex Villanueva was endorsed by the Los Angeles Progressive.